At what point do people have the right to defend themselves

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, May 23, 2014

Piketty's book contained data errors that completely drove his results

Posted on 1:39 PM by kitkat boom
UPDATE: Piketty is being accused of deliberately lying about his data to get the results that he wants.
Piketty altered U.K. data to show that wealth distribution there is worse off than it appears to be. 
Piketty says the share of income going to the top 10% never fell lower than 60%, and since the end of the 1970s has returned to 70%, a level not seen in 70 years.But the data Piketty himself cites shows the top 10% share of wealth is no greater than 50%, and may be as low as 42%. 
Giles writes: "This appears to be the result of swapping between data sources, not following the source notes, misinterpreting the more recent data and exaggerating increases in wealth inequality."  
Below is the chart. The right-most portion of Piketty's blue trend line showing the share of wealth owned by the top 10% of Britons ends up well above what's suggested by the data, in red, that Piketty himself cites.
Meanwhile, just one official data point for the top 1% share of wealth aligns with Piketty's blue line. But Giles said the source of that data said it was not suitable for the kind of calculation Piketty is trying to make. 
"Prof. Piketty ends his series taking at face value the level of the HMRC data, despite HMRC saying clearly the data is not suited for that purpose, nor is it consistent with the old Inland Revenue Series which Prof. Piketty uses for earlier years. This latter point is also clearly stated in the notes to the source data.". . .
Raw UK wealth inequality 1810 to 2010 590x395

ORIGINAL: The Financial Times has "found mistakes and unexplained entries in his spreadsheets, similar to those which last year undermined the work on public debt and growth of Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff."
The investigation undercuts this claim, indicating there is little evidence in Prof Piketty’s original sources to bear out the thesis that an increasing share of total wealth is held by the richest few. 
Prof Piketty, 43, provides detailed sourcing for his estimates of wealth inequality in Europe and the US over the past 200 years. In his spreadsheets, however, there are transcription errors from the original sources and incorrect formulas. It also appears that some of the data are cherry-picked or constructed without an original source.
For example, once the FT cleaned up and simplified the data, the European numbers do not show any tendency towards rising wealth inequality after 1970. An independent specialist in measuring inequality shared the FT’s concerns.  . . . 
Professor Joseph Stiglitz of Columbia University said Prof Piketty’s “fundamental contribution” was the provision of data on the distribution of wealth. . . . .
Like many, Robert Shiller, a liberal economist at Yale, was not impressed with Piketty's solutions, but he was impressed with the data:
Thomas Piketty’s impressive and much-discussed book Capital in the Twenty-First Century has brought considerable attention to the problem of rising economic inequality. But it is not strong on solutions. As Piketty admits, his proposal – a progressive global tax on capital (or wealth) – “would require a very high and no doubt unrealistic level of international cooperation.” . . .
So what do Shiller and Stiglitz say now?  They put a lot of weight on that data and the comparisons that were made.  Now those same comparisons show the opposite of what they claimed do they reverse their positions?  Paul Krugman believed that the book “will be the most important economics book of the year – and maybe of the decade.”

Of course, there were lots of logical errors in Piketty's book, but these data errors mean that even ignoring those problems his data doesn't show the increase in inequality that he was claiming.


As someone who hasn't put so much weight on these types of discussions, I don't really care what the results show on this, but for those who do, I will be interested in knowing how they handle this.

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in Fraud, wealthtransfers | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • While Democrats are outraged about the Koch brothers spending $30 million so far on campaigns, Tom Steyer pledges $100 million to back Democrats on Global Warming
    While Harry Reid keeps going to the floor of the Senate to denounce the Koch brothers, the  Kochs were notable donors to Democrats up to 201...
  • Piketty's book contained data errors that completely drove his results
    UPDATE :  Piketty is being accused of deliberately lying about his data to get the results that he wants. Piketty altered U.K. data to show...
  • Obama administration caught withholding unflattering data on Obamacare, Sebelius claim that "we don't collect" that data is a lie
    This is hardly surprising, but the fact that the Obama administration is consciously withholding data that would hurt their case should be m...
  • The subsidy for students going to state colleges keeps going up and up
    Click on figure to enlarge it. A lot is being made about the fact that students at public universities are covering a greater percentage of ...
  • Push for vote fraud in Louisiana: Democratic mayor urges voters to vote twice and assures them that the Democratic District Attorney will protect them from criminal charges
    For a second I thought that these statements might have been made as a joke, but it is pretty clear that it wasn't a joke, particularly ...
  • For Coast-to-Coast AM listeners: information on "Dumbing Down the Courts"
    Reviews and debates on my book Dumbing Down the Courts is available here .
  • With riots still going on in Ferguson, the New York Times publishes Darren Wilson's address
    From Howard Kurtz over at Fox News: The New York Times, whether consciously or not, has just endangered Darren Wilson’s life.   With tension...
  • Armed smash and grab cell phone thieves stopped by armed employee
    St. Louis has been plagued for years by armed robbers who break into cell phone stores and steal all the cell phones that they can grab. An ...
  • Gun control advocates attack American Hero Chris Kyle
    What could possibly justify these vicious comments?  Will gun control advocates keep this movie from "the Oscar spotlight"?  From ...
  • Papa John's lets pizza delivery woman who shot armed robber keep her job, Police: "She had no other choice"
    As the police say, the pizza delivery woman "had no other choice" and she would have been in real danger if she hadn't had her...

Categories

  • 2010election
  • 2012election
  • 2014elections
  • 2016 election
  • 3D Printed Gun
  • absurd gun law
  • Academia
  • accidentaldeaths
  • AffirmativeAction
  • APgate
  • appearances
  • apple
  • assaultweaponsban
  • At the Brink
  • Athletes
  • Australia
  • background checks
  • BATF
  • Benghazi
  • Bergdahl
  • Bitcoin
  • Blacks Concealed Carry
  • Bloomberg
  • Bob Costas
  • brokenpromisesobama
  • Brookings Institution
  • Bruce Braley
  • CampaignFinanceRegulation
  • Canada
  • cancer
  • CastleLaw
  • Chicago
  • china
  • CNN
  • communism
  • ConcealedCarry
  • corporations
  • Corruption
  • Crime
  • Crime Prevention Research Center
  • DC
  • de Blasio
  • Death
  • DeathPenalty
  • defensive gun use by child
  • DefensiveGunUse
  • DefensiveGunUse1
  • Democrats
  • demonizingrepublicans
  • Dinesh D'Souza
  • drones
  • druggangs
  • drugs
  • Dumbing Down the Courts
  • Economics
  • Economy
  • education
  • electric cars
  • Environment
  • EPA
  • EPAgate
  • EricHolder
  • EU
  • FDA
  • FirstAmendment
  • Frank Miniter
  • Fraud
  • Fun
  • Gabrielle Giffords
  • Gary Becker
  • GDP
  • george zimmerman
  • GlobalWarming
  • Google
  • Government
  • governmentcontrol
  • governmentwaste
  • Gun Control Poll
  • gunban
  • gunconfiscation
  • GunControl
  • GunFreeZone
  • gunlocks
  • gunownershiprate
  • Guns
  • Guns in Media
  • harryreid
  • Health
  • healthcare
  • Hillary Clinton Corruption
  • Hillary Clinton Gun Control
  • Hillary Clinton Mistakes
  • HillaryClinton
  • homosexualmarriage
  • hypocrisy of gun control advocates
  • IllegalAliens
  • income tax
  • insidertrading
  • IRSgate
  • James O'Keefe
  • JimSteyer
  • JoeBiden
  • John Walsh
  • Jonathan Gruber
  • Ken Rogoff
  • Knife
  • lead
  • Leland Yee
  • MaximLott
  • Mayors Against Illegal Guns
  • Media
  • media matters Lott
  • MediaAppearance
  • mediabias
  • mediamatters
  • mental illness gun control
  • Mexico
  • MGLCreviews
  • Michael Brown Ferguson Missouri
  • military
  • MinimumWage
  • Monopoly
  • multiple attackers
  • multiple defensive shots
  • multiplevictimcarattack
  • multiplevictimnongunattacks
  • multiplevictimpublicshooters
  • multiplevictimpublicshooters nonUS
  • newjersey
  • Newtown Attack
  • NICS
  • NSAgate
  • nullification
  • numberpermits
  • Obama
  • Obama Foreign Policy
  • Obama Waste
  • ObamaAdministration
  • obamacare
  • obamacare enrollment
  • ObamaCorruption
  • ObamaDishonest
  • obamadoesntunderstandeconomics
  • ObamaGunControl
  • obamajudicialappointments
  • obamalawless
  • obamaleftwing
  • ObamaMisstatement
  • Obamaprivacy
  • Obamatreatmentmedia
  • op-ed
  • OpenCarry
  • Other
  • Palin
  • PaulBegala
  • piersmorgan
  • Piketty
  • Police
  • Police Chief James Craig
  • police racism
  • Police State in US
  • PoliticalCorrectness
  • poll
  • postedgunfreezone
  • privacy
  • privatization
  • ProsecutorialAbuse
  • prostitution
  • pseudonym
  • Public Schools
  • racialdiscrimination
  • Radio
  • RahmEmanuel
  • redistricting
  • Regulation
  • religion
  • RickPerry
  • right-to-work
  • Russia
  • Santa Barbara Shooting
  • scandal
  • schoolsecurity
  • SecondAmendment
  • sexist
  • sexual harassment
  • SharylAttkisson
  • Sheriff David Clarke
  • smart gun technology
  • SmokingBan
  • socialism
  • Soros
  • sports
  • StateDepartmentgate
  • SteveLevitt
  • stimulus
  • StudentsforCConCampus
  • SupremeCourt
  • Talks
  • Taxes
  • Taylor Woolrich
  • technology undermining gov regulation
  • technologycausingcrime
  • technologysavinglives
  • technologysolvingcrime
  • television
  • Terrorism
  • thugishgovernment
  • Tina Fey
  • TomCorbett
  • transparency
  • TSA
  • UK
  • UN
  • unemployment
  • Unions
  • VAgate
  • VoteFraud
  • voting
  • waitingperiod
  • wealthtransfers
  • Wikipedia
  • womenssuffrage
  • womenversusmen
  • ZeroTolerance

Blog Archive

  • ►  2015 (13)
    • ►  January (13)
  • ▼  2014 (487)
    • ►  December (40)
    • ►  November (33)
    • ►  October (53)
    • ►  September (45)
    • ►  August (37)
    • ►  July (42)
    • ►  June (52)
    • ▼  May (77)
      • In the Santa Barbara killings, the media tries to ...
      • Britain's National Ballistics Intelligence Service...
      • Continued media misinformation on gun-free zones a...
      • "Wide support for 'gun violence restraining orders'"
      • Seriously? Father faced criminal penalties for ha...
      • Media Matters gets things wrong again: "Gun Resear...
      • House Democrats consider pushing gun control this ...
      • Economy shrinks by 1 percent in First Quarter
      • Newest piece at National Review Online: "Bloomberg...
      • Newest Fox News piece: Memo to gun-control advocat...
      • This is getting very embarrassing: After first not...
      • Do you want an idea of how difficult it is to use ...
      • Do mentally ill, multiple victim killers purposefu...
      • My review of Piketty's book at Amazon
      • Piketty's incredibly weak response to the Financia...
      • The push for gun control after the Santa Barbara a...
      • New Breitbart article on the Crime Prevention Rese...
      • In push for gun control, Bloomberg's Moms Demand A...
      • Another mass killer who probably supported gun con...
      • Democrats pushing for $60 million to "study" gun v...
      • Six people killed, seven wounded in deadly multipl...
      • A sensible policy on open carry of long guns
      • Jews apparently targeted in shooting at Brussels J...
      • The coming massive health insurance bailout
      • Six of the eight federal judges who have struck do...
      • Piketty's book contained data errors that complete...
      • With all the corruption and unnecessary deaths in ...
      • Congressionally Redistricting in Democratically Co...
      • Front door sign banning guns apparently didn't sto...
      • North Carolina homeowner shots one of four intrude...
      • Politico poll shows "mounting danger for Democrats"
      • On Washington DC's WMAL: Chipotle asked its custom...
      • So what caused crime rates to go up in 2012 in Chi...
      • My newest piece at National Review Online: "A Repl...
      • "Conservative Filmmaker D’Souza Pleads Guilty to E...
      • Newest piece at National Review Online: "Another R...
      • Chipotle asked its customers to stop bringing guns...
      • Zero Tolerance wackiness: "Fencing Team Banned Fro...
      • General data on concealed handgun permits for five...
      • So what caused crime rates to go up in 2012 in Chi...
      • Waste in Chicago Police Department
      • Only 37 percent of Americans trust the federal gov...
      • Roundup of news on Veterans Affairs Scandal
      • Gallup: Percent of Americans who believe that deat...
      • Exciting new cancer treatment wipes out woman's ca...
      • Ending Democracy in the US?: Evidence of Obama's c...
      • With Drug Cartel Violence Rampant, Mexican governm...
      • $1.2 billion in tax dollars wasted on Obamacare co...
      • In 2013, Obama administration released 36,000 ille...
      • "UCLA prof says stats prove school's admissions il...
      • Bloomberg's groups claim victory in "Jack in the B...
      • With rampant corruption in even how crime statisti...
      • Newest piece at National Review: "Another Round in...
      • Is there even one death penalty execution where th...
      • Do you need more proof that government is ineffici...
      • "Rogoff-Reinhart data scandal"
      • Glenn Beck w/ John Lott author of "At The Brink"
      • Colorado's background check law prevents law-abidi...
      • More De Blasio hypocrisy, he cracks down on pedest...
      • So much for the claim that people are retiring ear...
      • Tea party donors audited at 10 times the rate of o...
      • Newest piece at National Review: "The Shaky Case a...
      • Missouri to vote on revised state constitutional p...
      • Ratio of self identified Republican to Democrat jo...
      • Federal Election Commission warns that it wants to...
      • Why gun control will be a very major issue in the ...
      • What is it with Bloomberg trying to take over nati...
      • Response to Jack D’Aurora's column in the Columbus...
      • Shaming people for crimes: Websites showing people...
      • Appearance on Judge Jeanine's show on Fox News: Wh...
      • Can someone name me one college where faculty have...
      • My son Maxim has a piece on Gary Becker at Fox News
      • The calm before the storm: polls moving in the rig...
      • Black Pastor says Stand Your Ground laws help blacks
      • Newest piece at Fox News: Media bias on gun free z...
      • How much do people like the state that they live i...
      • Nice review of More Guns, Less Crime by a board-ce...
    • ►  April (52)
    • ►  March (56)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

kitkat boom
View my complete profile